DJP Update 2-15-2019 A MUST READ BOOK! Childhood Abuse, Body Shame, and Addictive Plastic Surgery by Mark B. Constantian, MD
————
This book should be in every medical school curriculum. It is a cautionary tale for physicians and patients. It deserves to be a best seller. Uncovering the cause of a problem is a critical step in the cure. Read and admire Dr. Constantian’s research, discovery, and solution offering hope for the future.
Lagniappe: Did you know that JAMA and the New England Journal of Medicine no longer do book reviews? In my opinion, that is a loss. Encourage your state and specialty societies to review this book.
“Mark B. Constantian, MD, FACS, has practiced plastic surgery in Nashua, New Hampshire, since 1978 and has faculty appointments at the University of Wisconsin and the University of Virginia. He is the author of more than 100 professional journal articles and book chapters and two previous textbooks, including Rhinoplasty: Craft and Magic.”
My review at Amazon:
Dr. Mark Constantian, a brilliant, accomplished surgeon, becomes a modern day Sherlock Holmes to uncover the causes of a grand theft of self-esteem in some patients and the never-ending quest for an illusory body perfection through plastic surgery. Meticulously researched and illustrated with evocative vignettes, readers will enjoy this as much as a suspense thriller. Highly recommended for physicians and patients.
Donald J. Palmisano, MD, JD, FACS, Former President of the American Medical Association, Clinical Professor of Surgery and Clinical Professor of Medical Jurisprudence at Tulane University School of Medicine
——-
Kirkus Review:
KIRKUS REVIEW
A plastic surgeon presents insights into patients’ motivations based on his practice and empirical research.
In this medical book, Constantian (Rhinoplasty, 2009) analyzes patients who have undergone multiple cosmetic surgeries and are unsatisfied with the results, finding that their reactions can often be connected to disturbing childhood experiences. The author combines anonymous anecdotes from his patients with peer-reviewed research into the lasting impacts of traumatic events in childhood to show that many cases are the result of patients’ reactions to family dysfunction or abuse. He argues that the pursuit of elective cosmetic surgery—rhinoplasties, or nose jobs, in Constantian’s practice—should be understood in that context. The deeply researched book (each chapter includes several pages of endnotes, and full credit is given to existing rubrics like the Mellody model) takes readers through existing literature on human psychology, including body dysmorphic disorder, an exploration of how behaviors related to body image can be a response to trauma, and the physiological effects of painful experiences. He concludes that patients can be best served by developing a sense of resilience and dealing with the underlying issues as opposed to going to surgeons who simply accede to requests to lengthen or shorten their nose tips by a few millimeters. The author urges physicians to understand the “intensity of emotion” that may be involved in a case and to acknowledge the connections between emotional state and physical health.
The writing here is strong, though certainly technical, and it is clear from the opening pages that the book is intended as a professional reference rather than casual reading material. The target audience is surgeons, and understanding that keeps the authoritative narrative tone from becoming overbearing (“Physicians see the effects of this neglect in patients who become childlike following surgery, or in Internet conversations where patients give medical advice to each other or pose questions that should be directed to their surgeons—or not even asked”). Although the patients who appear in the work’s many anecdotes may appear extreme (one’s “six-page letter read like the Unabomber Manifesto”), Constantian provides a level of detail and empathy that renders them entirely plausible, allowing readers to see how domineering parents, the lasting effects of physical abuse, or other childhood traumas can shape patients’ enduring unhealthy relationships with their bodies. The volume’s conclusions are based on solid science, and the author acknowledges socio-economic factors that may further shape patients’ responses. The occasional bits of humor (“If I were marooned with her for three days, she could probably turn me into Prufrock”) add a distinctive touch without detracting from the treatment of a serious subject. The concrete and actionable information provided gives readers useful takeaways, like comparisons of satisfaction rates between patients correcting real deformities and those having features that appear normal to a casual observer. There is some discussion of how patients can develop the resilience that seems to be the most effective way of managing these disorders, but the book remains focused on its readers, providing surgeons with guidance on improving their interactions with troublesome patients.
A solid, well-researched, and well-argued analysis of the behavior of plastic surgery patients.
Pub Date: Dec. 13th, 2018
ISBN: 978-1-138-10030-5
Page count: 342pp
Publisher: Routledge
Review Posted Online: Feb. 13th, 2019
———————-
Stay well,
Donald
Donald J. Palmisano, MD, JD, FACS
Donald J Palmisano Consulting
Intrepid Resources®
5000 West Esplanade Ave., #432
Metairie, LA 70006
USA
504-455-5895 office
(Author of ON LEADERSHIP (2008, 2011 2nd edition) and THE LITTLE RED BOOK OF LEADERSHIP LESSONS (2012 in bookstores and AMAZON)
DJP Updates:
This DJP Update started out going to leaders in Medicine representing all of the State Medical Associations and over 100 Specialty Societies plus some other friends; and now around the globe via Twitter followers.
You can share it with your members and it has the potential to reach 800,000 physicians.
To join the list, send me an email stating “Join DJP Update”
To get off the list, state ” Remove DJP Update” in subject line.
NOTE: IF YOU ELECT TO GET OFF OF THIS MAILING, PLEASE SEND ME ALL EMAIL ADDRESSES YOU USE IF YOUR OLD EMAIL IS FORWARDING TO YOUR NEW EMAIL BECAUSE THE LIST IS BY EMAIL AND NOT NAME. IF YOU SEND ME ONLY YOUR NEW EMAIL, I WON’T FIND YOU TO REMOVE. THANKS!
